Skip to main content

If Political Science is Widely Regarded as Irrelevant to Real Politics, What Can be Done to Reverse that View?

Let Google AI Answer that Question with its Own Book Review:

The main argument of William J. Kelleher's book, Normative Political Science: An Exciting New Way to Do Poli Sci Research, is that it is possible to scientifically measure the "operational goodness" of a political system. Rather than relying on subjective moral philosophy, Kelleher proposes a method that combines two established theories to provide an objective, data-driven evaluation. 

Key components of the argument

1. Integration of established theories

Kelleher's methodology is based on two frameworks:

  • David Easton's Systems Theory: This theory conceptualizes a political system in terms of inputs, processes, and outputs. The system converts demands and support from the public into policies and decisions. Kelleher uses this as a "blueprint" for a political system.
  • Robert S. Hartman's Value Science: This formal axiology provides a framework for measuring the "goodness" of things by assessing how well a specimen fulfills the conceptual definition of its category. 

2. Assessing "operational goodness"

By combining Easton and Hartman, Kelleher argues that the "operational goodness" of a political system can be measured by comparing its actual performance against the conceptual expectations laid out in Easton's model. This allows political scientists to: 

  • Rate and compare systems: Systems can be rated as "excellent," "adequate," or "poor," and compared to other systems.
  • Pinpoint dysfunctions: The method helps identify exactly where a system is failing to meet its operational specifications, highlighting specific dysfunctions. 

3. Incorporation of public opinion

The book recognizes that unlike a mechanical system, a political system's "operational goodness" must also account for the human element. Public opinion regarding the system's performance is used as an additional measure, with well-functioning systems likely to receive supportive attitudes and vice versa. 

4. Prescription of remedial policies

By identifying system deficiencies based on scientific observation rather than moral judgment, the approach shifts political science toward an applied, problem-solving discipline. 

  • Proposing solutions: Political scientists can suggest remedial policies to address diagnosed problems, improving the system's operation.
  • Raising the profession's standing: This provides a pathway for political science to be seen as a reliable source of public policy wisdom, potentially raising the profession's standing. 

The bridge between "is" and "ought"

Ultimately, Kelleher's book seeks to bridge the traditional gap between descriptive (empirical) and prescriptive (normative) political science. By using empirical observations to determine how well the "ought" of the political system is being fulfilled, he proposes a method for deriving practical policy solutions from scientific analysis. 

The above is Google AI's exact answer to this question, What are the main arguments in the book, Normative Political Science, by William Kelleher?

William J. Kelleher, PhD

"Together, we can make Political Science better!"

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Red Roulette, by a Billionaire Chinese Crybaby

Introduction After it all, “I thought that China wasn’t as bad as Americans tended to think.” (182) That’s the conclusion of billionaire Desmond Shum, author of Red Roulette* – his autobiographical account of how he and his wife, Whitney Duan, rose from rags to riches in the go-go years of China’s developmental miracle. Whitney and the Road to Wealth Born in the late 1960s, during the Cultural Revolution, both Whitney and Desmond received a normal education as children. She then enrolled in a military university in 1986. (73) As an outstanding student, she obtained employment as an executive’s assistant in “a real estate development company run by China’s military.” (74) At the time, the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) had numerous business interests, and Whitney started making connections with the elite among them. Later, the PLA was ordered to divest itself of these businesses as an anti-corruption measure by CCP General Secretary, Jiang Zemin in 1997. (75) The year before that, pe...

RIP Prop 33 😭 What happened?

Why did Prop 33 lose in California? Here are three reasons, although there could be more:  1) Out of state billionaire real estate special interests, combined with in-state millionaire Landlord orgs, spent over $121,000,000 on telling scary falsehoods to Californians. Like, rent control will cause rents to go up, and affordable housing will disappear. They just needed to cause enough confusion about the meaning of Prop 33 to get the voters – even tenants! – to vote no.   2) As I explain in a vid on YouTube,* the California Legislative Analyst presented a biased and negative summary of Prop 33 in the Voter Guide. That was sent out to 22M Californians. For many voters, it was the one and only thing they would read about Prop 33. The law requires the Legislative Analyst to suggest the economic impact of a prop for both state and local gov – but only a negative view was given, and only for the state gov – “tens of millions” would be lost in tax revenues, it said. But renters w...
The Democratic Party is Responsible for the Election of Trump 1) In the 90s they started Globalization. Like Ross Perot warned, millions of jobs were lost, leaving millions of angry ex-workers. 2) No help was given them. The Bill Clinton administration could have enacted something like the GI Bill after WWII. Instead, those out of work were left to smolder for nearly 20 years, while the Dem Billionaires got richer. 3)   Then came the 2008 crash with all its too easy to get mortgages. The Obama Dems didn't do one thing to help folks avoid foreclosure, or help after they lost their home. Instead, the Bank Bailout, passed under Bush, was implemented under Obama. Out of this came a whole lot more angry people. 4) Then the Dems cheated us out of Bernie’s candidacy in 2016. Polls showed he could have beaten Trump. This is because he spoke to those Victims of Globalization and Bankster Fraud who had become a voting block. 5) Hillary Clinton didn’t acknowledge those folks. But Trump promis...